Nutrient and grazing factors in relation to phytoplankton level in a eutrophic shallow lake: The effect of low macrophyte abundance

The ability of submerged macrophytes to moderate the structure of food webs with respect to lake eutrophication management has been intensively studied in recent years. Many lake managers have adopted the option of increasing macrophyte abundance in order to restore eutrophic waters, with a view to improve water quality, increase water transparency and reduce phytoplankton biomass. These studies are mostly based upon the comparison of macrophyte-rich and macrophyte-free waters. There is less quantitative information on how different levels of macrophyte abundance, in particular very low levels, influence ecosystem structure, or vice versa, within the same ecosystem. This paper takes a multivariate statistical approach to examine ecosystem function with low macrophyte abundance (ca. 5%) in the context of nutrient–phytoplankton–zooplankton interaction in a eutrophic shallow lake. It shows that with low levels of macrophyte coverage, phytoplankton biomass was only limited by nutrient (TP and Si) availability, whilst nutrient (Si) as well as grazing (zooplankton and Daphnia) factors were both limiting phytoplankton levels in macrophyte-free waters. With respect to interactions between Daphnia and chlorophyll-a, the results suggest that low macrophyte cover does not result in a reduction of phytoplankton biomass due to the presence of Daphnia. Rather, low macrophyte cover provides a refuge that maintains constant Daphnia predation, so reducing chlorophyll-a fluctuation. These results add credence to the causal interpretation of different interactions amongst nutrients, phytoplankton and zooplankton at very low macrophyte densities.